The roadside clearing along Soda Canyon Road and Atlas Peak, and the fuel break around Circle Oaks, were paid for under Napa County contracts with Napa Firewise.
A review of those contracts by the county auditor’s office, dated June 24, found the nonprofit had overbilled for overhead. It also found that three of its six contracts were never put out to bid, with no documented, approved reason for skipping it.
Measure B, a half-cent sales tax for wildfire work and open space, was leading 33,501 to 19,612 in the county’s Nov. 16 unofficial count. That’s 63.07%. Under the measure, half the money goes to the county, which must hand it out, with some exceptions, as competitive grants to nonprofits.
Napa Firewise’s CEO, Joe Nordlinger, signed the ballot argument for Measure B.
What the auditor found
The Board of Supervisors asked for the review at its May 5 meeting. The auditor’s office looked at six contracts the county has signed with Napa Firewise since July 2023. Together they total more than $21.4 million. The report says the office was not hired to do an audit and gives no opinion on the accounts. It calls itself a contract review.
Overhead is the cost of running the group itself that can’t be pinned to one project. The contracts let Napa Firewise bill 10% on top of its direct costs, the spending tied to its projects, to cover it. Equipment and rentals didn’t count toward that 10%.
Only part of each subcontract counted: the first $25,000 or $50,000, depending on the contract. Napa Firewise applied the limit to each invoice instead of each subcontract, so more of each subcontract counted. On three active contracts, that pushed its overhead bills too high.
The total was $61,684.07. The biggest piece, $45,344.47, was on the largest active contract. “NCFF was notified of the issue during our review and agreed to adjust future reimbursement claims to offset the overbilled amounts,” the report says. NCFF is the foundation’s initials.
On the finished contracts, the report says “no repayment is required.” Napa Firewise drew its overhead money faster than it should have, but not more of it in total.
The auditor also found that most of the contracts let Napa Firewise collect overhead two ways. It could add 10% to its subcontractors’ bills and also bill 10% overhead on its own direct costs. The auditor put the combined rate at about 12% and said that “does not appear unreasonable.” But using both “may reduce transparency and create the appearance of overlapping cost recovery,” the report says. Napa Firewise agreed to use only the 10% markup in future contracts.
The board approved all six contracts. But the report says “only three were awarded through a competitive procurement process.” The other three had no documented, approved reason for skipping bids. The auditor recommended that future contracts either be bid or come with that reason in writing.
Overall, the auditor wrote that “no significant control deficiencies or irregularities were identified.” Payroll and other costs the auditor checked were backed up, and invoices were reviewed before the county paid them.
Another contract, without bids
The board accepted the review on July 28, on its consent calendar, a list of items approved in one vote. The vote was 4-0, with Supervisor Amber Manfree excused.
A new $3.2 million Napa Firewise contract was on the same agenda. It was removed from the agenda.
It came back Aug. 25. The board approved it 5-0, again on consent, with no bids. It runs through June 30, 2027.
The staff report, by Shana Bagley, interim fire administrator, gave three reasons to skip bidding: “uniqueness, timeliness, and inadequate competition.” It also said: “This sole source request is in compliance with the recommendations in the most recent contract audit.”
The new contract sets hourly rates for Napa Firewise staff. The CEO’s rate is $225 an hour. It adds a 10% markup on vendor invoices. Of the $3.2 million, $2,465,000 is for fuel mitigation. The staff report lists that work as roadside clearing, fuel breaks and grazing to reduce what can burn.
Napa Firewise worked for the county before July 2023, too. Agreements that began in September 2020 and ran through December 2023 came to $14,166,000.
What Measure B adds
Measure B runs from April 1, 2027, to March 31, 2045. Its backers estimate in the measure’s text that it will raise about $23 million a year. It splits the money evenly between the county and the Napa County Regional Park and Open Space District.
The county’s half must go out as “competitive Grants to Qualified 501 c3 Nonprofit Organizations.” A citizen committee will watch the spending, and the measure calls for “annual independent audits.” Every grant agreement must give the county the right to inspect and audit, and must include clawback provisions, which let the county take money back.
The tax is set to start April 1, 2027. Napa Firewise’s unbid contract runs through June 30, 2027.