Buddy, a 79-pound dog about 10 years old, came to the Clearlake City Council meeting Thursday, Nov. 19, looking for a home. He has lived at the city’s animal shelter since Aug. 13.
He is one of 45 dogs at a shelter the nonprofit that runs it says is near capacity. The same night, the council told the Lake County civil grand jury it has no money right now to add to the shelter’s budget. The city pays $375,000 a year to run it.
The council voted 5-0 to approve its response to the jury’s report on the shelter, “Clearlake Animal Services — New Leash On Life.” The jury asked the city to raise the animal services budget every year to keep up with the cost of living. The city’s answer: “Will not be implemented.”
“The City does not currently have additional discretionary funding available for animal services without reducing other essential services,” the response says.
At the meeting, Vice Mayor Tara Downey pulled the item from the consent agenda. As drafted, she said, the funding answer “seemed like a hard shut off.” So the council added language that leaves the door open.
The language she read aloud says “the council recognizes that the current funding levels limit the ability to fully address the community’s animal care and control needs.” It adds that the council “desires to increase funding for these services as additional financial resources become available.”
What the jury found
The Clearlake Animal Association, a nonprofit, took over the shelter at 6820 Old Highway 53 in February. The city moved in August 2025 to end its contract with North Bay Animal Services, which had run the shelter since 2023.
On a November 2025 tour, jurors found a shelter equipped to house 25 dogs holding 61, the grand jury’s final report says. When the association took over, it found 114 dogs and puppies, unvaccinated and malnourished, the report says.
Since then, the jury wrote, the association has cleaned up the shelter and found places for many of the dogs. But it called the money short. “The contract is only $375,000 a year, which does not cover the costs of employee wages, insurance, shelter management, maintenance, and care of the dogs,” the report says. Food, supplies and medical care come from donations, it says.
On Jan. 15, the council approved the contract 5-0. It pays the same $375,000 the city paid North Bay Animal Services, the staff report says. The association sent the only proposal the city received.
The shelter this month
The association gives the council a report each month. On Nov. 19, an association staff member said the shelter took in 62 animals in the past month: 39 dogs, 21 stray cats and two fish. Nineteen of the dogs were given up by their owners.
In the same month, 41 animals were adopted, 26 went to other groups, five dogs went home to their owners and 12 animals were euthanized. Two cats died in the shelter’s care.
As of Nov. 18, 45 dogs and 12 cats were at the shelter, and 29 dogs and 33 cats were in foster homes. Asked whether the shelter was full, she said it was “pretty close.”
A council member said 10 dogs headed to the Humane Society of Sonoma County on Nov. 19 to be spayed or neutered. The society kept all 10.
Where the city and the jury disagree
The jury wrote that on the night of May 9, someone cut the gate lock and stole a dog the association had taken in the day before. The shelter has no security cameras. The jury said the theft was reported to the Clearlake Police Department, which didn’t investigate.
Police Chief Timothy Hobbs gave a different account. A police lieutenant told an association worker to call the patrol division and file a report, he wrote. Dispatch records show no such call.
The jury found the shelter out of compliance with Cal/OSHA workplace safety rules. The city’s response says Cal/OSHA issued three citations to the association, as the employer, after a June inspection. Cal/OSHA told the city that no further action was required of it on that inspection, the response says.
The city turned down the jury’s call for a citizens’ oversight board. The city manager and police chief meet with the association’s director every month, the response says.
What comes next
The contract runs one year from Feb. 7, with up to two one-year extensions at the city’s option. The association owes the city a yearly performance report by Jan. 31, and the council gets the review in February.